data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c6917/c6917cd7db530a1fef512d4b86c09668be541201" alt="Battle for dream island ice cube"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/84260/84260dbc7deb347b999e0a809178fd1e7b084a4a" alt="battle for dream island ice cube battle for dream island ice cube"
Pencil returned in Battle for Dream Island Again. She was eliminated in the nineteenth episode, Rescission. She bullies Ice Cube and Bubble for not being good enough. Pencil made her official debut in Battle for Dream Island as a contestant on the Squishy Cherries. She competed in yet another prototypical version of Battle for Dream Island known as "Total Firey Points", but her placement is unknown.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/57fde/57fdeadfedb4e453b671187531bc07ba6538dd73" alt="battle for dream island ice cube battle for dream island ice cube"
She later competed in a precursor to the show in a comic book series known as "Total Firey Island", in which she won the "show". Pencil was created during summer of 2008 as a character in the "Firey" comic book series. She is later shown to be a misandrist, as she expresses disgust when a group of male contestants enter the EXIT. She is also sadistic and sociopathic and will go out of her way to torture contestants that she hates, as seen when she stops Bubble from going against "the alliance's objective" so she could watch Fanny being electrocuted for her own amusement. In Battle for BFDI, Pencil becomes a control freak and toxic leader, taking advantage of Bubble's nature as a pushover in order to keep her under her thumb. In IDFB, Pencil seems to be more detached from her relationships, as seen when she insults Match, her best friend, behind her back while she was eliminated. From there, her more antagonistic side was shown, such as cheating by helping another contestant (Match) avoid elimination, bullying Ruby to tears, and referring to Book and Ice Cube as "monsters". In Battle for Dream Island Again, she revolts from Team No-Name and forms a team with her alliance, FreeSmart. Pencil was overall nice in the show until the third episode of Battle for Dream Island where she ridicules Bubble for being dumb and her "inability" to count to 3.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d4600/d460093b1419cb14a773c50aa0a4ce6aa0afecdd" alt="battle for dream island ice cube battle for dream island ice cube"
Pencil often likes to add slang abbreviations to her sentences and has an inseparable best friend, Match. Pencil is depicted as acting somewhat like a teenage girl, similar to Match, but less to an extent. Pencil, along with Match, was one of the first 2 contestants seen on-screen in the very first episode of the show, Take the Plunge. Between BFDI and BFDIA, her eyes and mouth were moved closer together. Her metal is silver, and her eraser is pink. Her tip is beige, her graphite is a dark gray, and her main body is three shades of orange. 2 graphite pencil, a pencil most commonly used for writing.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c6917/c6917cd7db530a1fef512d4b86c09668be541201" alt="Battle for dream island ice cube"